If you've been following the case, by now you've read that after some lengthy deliberations,
the jury has made the decision that Dale Neumann, (like his wife Leilani) committed second degree reckless manslaughter when they opted out of medical care for prayer.
While justice prevailed in this case, technically in Wisconsin, religious parents have the privilege to abuse, maim, and kill their children. (Christian Scientists wanted these exemptions in the past.) This means, as a parent, if you believe that sickness is caused by sin and that your child's illness is a test of
your faith, or by seeking medical care you are being disobedient to god, no legal action can be taken against you.
Imagine for a moment that as a component of someone's faith that first degree, ritual murder is a requirement. As a society, we do not give you this privilege to murder just because that is your belief. Legally, you are under no obligation to surrender that belief, however, other laws hold you under obligation to not commit murder.
Forget religion, if you are a parent or guardian and you allow your child to suffer and die by malnutrition or physical abuse and you do not have religious reasons for doing so, the full child abuse laws apply against you. However, if this form of child abuse is done as a consequence of the parent's religion, these parents are exempt from any criminal responsibility.
Fortunately, in Kara Neumann's case, jurors saw through this inequity.
Currently under draft, State Representative,
Terese Berceau, will introduce legislation, LRB-2190, to remove these privileges by repealing, amending, or eliminating these privileges altogether.
In short, LRB-2190 aims to repeal state statue
948.03 (6). Presently, if a parent or legal guardian treats a minor only through prayer (or other spiritual means) and bodily harm, or death should result, there are no penalties or liabilities. With its repeal, this exception will be eliminated. The bill will also amend
448.03 (6) defining that only an adult who practices Christian Science may treat themselves with faith healing or prayer, and not just a "person." Furthermore, the bill will eliminate two other exceptions, by amending
48.981 (3) and
938.505 (2) (a) thereby ending these privileges altogether.
If you live in Wisconsin and you want to end this type of religiously motivated-abuse and restore access to health care for these children whose parents are unfortunately sincere in their beliefs like the Neumanns,
please contact your state legislator and ask them to support
LRB-2190.
For more information:
1.
Proposed faith-healing bills under scrutiny 2.
Police: Girl died as parents prayed instead of seeking help3.
Parents turn grief into a mission: Change the laws4.
Daniel Hauser in parents' custody; begins chemo tomorrow5.
Trial Begins In Faith-Healing Death Case